A few days ago, there was a discussion in a group of wine enthusiasts about this topic. During the exchange of opinions, someone mentioned the Wine Etiquette. We were convinced that the issue was fairly straightforward; however, as we looked deeper, we discovered some truly interesting aspects.

For this reason, we decided to do some research, study the topic and ultimately write this article in which we aim to clarify whether it is appropriate or not to comment on wine at the table.

Is it appropriate to comment on wine at the table? What does etiquette say?

The answer is: IT DEPENDS ON THE CONTEXT.

This should not come as a surprise, because, as with any aspect or detail, the Wine Etiquette guide is extremely precise and provides different recommendations depending on the situation, the level of formality of the event and the guests at the table.

At first glance, we can say that, according to Wine Etiquette, there are occasions when it is appropriate to comment on the wine with other diners and occasions when it is better to avoid making any comments.

It is natural, at this point, to wonder what these circumstances are. We will explore them in the following paragraphs: by the end of the reading, you will have a clear and complete understanding of when it is acceptable to comment on wine at the table and when it is not.

On which occasions, according to etiquette, is it appropriate to comment on wine at the table?

There are specific moments when commenting on the wine is appropriate and appreciated; in fact, it can be useful on a social level, as it helps create the right degree of conviviality.

The situations in which it is appropriate to comment on wine at the table are:

• PROFESSIONAL TASTINGS: the wine is the center of attention and commenting is part of the experience. In this context, sharing impressions and sensations is not only appropriate but also expected and, above all, useful: the exchange helps to better understand the wine, appreciate its nuances and enrich the tasting experience through the different perspectives of the participants.

• DINNERS AMONG ENTHUSIASTS: in an informal setting among passionate wine lovers, wine naturally becomes a topic of conversation. A discreet and measured comment is appropriate because it encourages the exchange of opinions, stimulates dialogue and helps create a convivial atmosphere.

• INFORMAL SETTINGS: when the dinner is among friends or family, commenting on the wine is generally acceptable. Even in this case, a respectful and discreet opinion stimulates conversation, enriches the experience and makes the evening more enjoyable without being intrusive.

• WHEN THE HOST INVITES COMMENTS: if the person who selected the wine asks for an opinion, giving feedback is not only appropriate but also expected. Sharing a positive judgment demonstrates participation, appreciation and attention toward the person who chose the wine, strengthening the convivial and respectful atmosphere at the table.

How to comment on wine at the table?

Once the situations in which it is appropriate to comment on wine are clear, the next question is naturally: how should one do it? The answer is simple: with grace and courtesy, which are the foundations of etiquette.

The Wine Etiquette guide also provides other very useful and practical tips to follow in any circumstance to comment on wine correctly.

If the context allows, the practical rules are as follows:

• Favor discreet and positive comments, even when the wine is not among your favorites.

• If a wine does not fully convince you, focus on one positive aspect.

• Avoid overly critical remarks.

• Use technical terms only in professional tastings or dinners among experts.

• Prefer simple and understandable language.

• Avoid comparing wines to prevent value judgments.

• Do not talk about price or vintage: the focus should remain on taste and the shared experience.

Following these rules helps to comment on wine in an elegant, pleasant and respectful way, transforming the table into a place of shared enjoyment and conviviality. According to Wine Etiquette, commenting on wine, except in professional tastings, should not be a technical exercise or a display of expertise, but rather a moment of social interaction. The main goal is to stimulate conversation and strengthen the social bond among guests, making wine a topic that enhances the conviviality of the occasion.

On which occasions, according to etiquette, should you NOT comment on wine at the table?

Now let’s look at the situations in which it is not advisable to comment on wine. According to Wine Etiquette, these are:

• IN FORMAL SETTINGS OR ELEGANT RESTAURANTS: in these contexts, the wine is often selected by the sommelier or the host with great care and professionalism. Etiquette therefore suggests enjoying the wine with discretion, appreciating its qualities without turning the moment into a “show of expertise,” so as not to embarrass other guests or disrupt the flow of conversation. The only exception is when the sommelier or host explicitly invites participants to give their opinion: in that case, it is possible to comment, always with moderation.

• WHEN THE COMMENT COULD SEEM CRITICAL OR OFFENSIVE: expressing negative or inappropriate judgments can offend the person who chose the wine or other guests. Etiquette emphasizes the importance of maintaining a positive and respectful tone, so in these situations, it is better to say nothing.

• IF YOU ARE NOT FAMILIAR WITH WINE: in these circumstances, it is better not to comment and simply enjoy the shared experience.

Now you know when it is appropriate to comment on wine at the table with other guests. Keep this short guide at hand to behave with elegance and discretion in every situation.